Helena had pictured at least a hundred different ways to tell Theo he was going to become a father.
Not one of those imagined moments included walking into their garage and discovering her husband kissing her best friend.
For six long months, the bathroom cabinet had filled with pregnancy tests that delivered the same disappointing result.
Each month, Helena promised herself she would stop counting the days, studying the calendar, and wondering whether every headache or passing spell of nausea meant something.
Then, on a rainy Friday morning, she finally saw two pink lines.
She lowered herself onto the bathroom floor and remained there for nearly ten minutes, unable to take her eyes off the test.
Positive.
Her immediate impulse was to call out Theo’s name as loudly as she could.
Instead, she pressed a hand over her mouth and began laughing through her tears.
That evening was their regular game night.
Simon and his wife, Camille, would be coming over, just as they had countless times before. Helena decided to keep her wonderful news to herself until their guests had gone home.
Then she would take Theo upstairs, place the pregnancy test in his hand, and watch the man she loved discover that the family they had dreamed about was finally becoming a reality.
Throughout the evening, she kept the test tucked inside the pocket of her elaborate pink-and-lavender dress.
As Theo opened a bottle of wine, he leaned over and kissed her forehead.
“You look incredible.”
Helena smiled at him.
“You might want to remember saying that.”
He smiled back.
“Why?”
“You’ll find out later.”
During dinner, Helena could hardly contain her excitement.
Across the table, Camille was laughing at one of Simon’s awful jokes.
Camille had been Helena’s friend for nine years.
She had stood beside Helena as her maid of honor on her wedding day.
She had held Helena’s hand after Helena’s first pregnancy scare turned out to be nothing.
And three months earlier, when Helena finally admitted she was frightened she might never have children, Camille had been the person she called.
“You will,” Camille had assured her.
Helena had trusted that promise.
She trusted Camille.
She trusted Theo.
She trusted every person sitting around that dinner table.
That was what made betrayal so devastating. Before someone could betray your trust, you had to give it to them.
By eleven o’clock, their board game had given way to laughter, empty glasses, and the familiar mess left behind after a pleasant evening with friends.
Simon volunteered to wash the dishes.
Theo headed toward the garage.
“Checking the freezer,” he explained.
Less than a minute afterward, Camille disappeared as well.
Helena noticed her absence only because she had been about to ask whether Camille wanted some coffee.
Then she heard laughter coming from behind the garage door.
Camille’s laughter.
Helena went to the door and opened it.
Theo had Camille pressed against the side of their car.
They were kissing.
There was nothing tentative about it.
Nothing suggested an accident or an innocent misunderstanding.
The way Theo’s hand rested around Camille’s waist was far too familiar.
For an instant, Helena couldn’t seem to draw a breath.
Theo was the first to notice her.
He pulled away abruptly.
“Helena.”
Camille turned toward the doorway.
The color drained from her face.
Helena stared at them both.
Through the glass connecting the garage to the kitchen, she could see Simon peacefully rinsing a dinner plate.
He didn’t know what was happening.
And until a few seconds earlier, neither had she.
“How long?”
“Helena, please,” Theo said. “It’s not what you think.”
Helena almost laughed at the absurdity of his response.
“What exactly should I think?”
Camille moved a step toward her.
“I can explain.”
“No.”
The word came out with a crack in Helena’s voice.
Theo glanced nervously toward the kitchen.
“Let’s not do this while Simon’s here.”
Something inside Helena finally gave way.
“He is here.”
Her hand moved into the pocket of her dress.
She took out the pregnancy test.
Theo stared at the small plastic object.
His expression transformed.
“Helena… is that—?”
But Helena had already turned toward the house.
“SIMON!”
Her shout carried straight through the kitchen.
Seconds later, Simon appeared in the doorway with a dish towel still clutched in his hand.
“What happened?”
Helena opened her mouth, but no words came.
She could only point toward Camille.
“Ask your wife.”
Simon studied the faces around him, trying to understand why everyone looked so shaken.
Then his eyes settled on the pregnancy test in Helena’s hand.
He turned toward Camille.
But instead of asking why she had been standing in the garage with Theo, Simon asked a question that made Theo become completely motionless.
“Does this have something to do with what you told me last month?”
Helena slowly lowered the test.
“What did she tell you?”
Simon looked utterly exhausted.
“Camille told me she was pregnant.”
The story isn’t over yet. Select “Next Part” below to see what happens next.
An oppressive silence settled over the garage.
Theo whispered a single word.
“What?”
Simon gave him an unusual look.
“That was approximately my reaction.”
Camille began crying.
“Simon—”
“No. We’re finished hiding things.”
He reached into his pocket and took out his phone.
“The dates didn’t make sense.”
Helena glanced from Camille to Theo, struggling to follow what Simon was saying.
“What dates?”
Simon’s expression hardened.
“Because eighteen months ago, I had a vasectomy.”
Theo moved backward.
Helena suddenly felt lightheaded.
Two women who were supposedly pregnant.
Two marriages.
And one affair connecting them.
Helena looked directly at Camille.
“Is Theo the father?”
Camille shook her head.
“No.”
Theo stared at her.
“What?”
“The baby isn’t yours.”
For the briefest moment, Helena felt something that almost resembled relief.
Then Camille spoke again.
“Theo and I only started this three weeks ago.”
Simon crossed his arms over his chest.
“Then whose baby is it?”
Camille turned her attention toward Helena.
What she said next sent the night in an entirely different direction.
“Ask Theo where he was during your sister’s engagement party.”
Helena went cold.
Her younger sister, Mara, had gotten engaged seven months earlier.
The celebration had ended terribly.
Mara had disappeared before midnight.
When Helena tried calling the following morning, her sister refused to answer.
Within a week, Mara had moved three states away.
They had barely spoken since.
Theo’s voice came out in a whisper.
“Camille, don’t.”
Helena faced him.
“Where were you?”
“It isn’t what she’s making it sound like.”
“Where?”
Theo shut his eyes.
“With Mara.”
Helena clapped a hand over her mouth.
Simon muttered, “Jesus.”
Theo immediately shook his head.
“Nothing happened between us.”
“Then why hide it?”
“Because Mara asked me to.”
Helena moved closer to her husband.
“You expect me to believe my sister secretly met my husband during her engagement party?”
“Yes.”
“For what?”
Theo looked toward Camille.
Camille dropped her eyes to the floor.
It was a tiny movement, but Helena noticed it immediately.
“You know,” she whispered.
Camille’s crying grew worse.
“Helena, I swear I wanted to tell you.”
“Then tell me now.”
Camille finally lifted her eyes.
“Mara discovered something.”
“What?”
“About Theo.”
Theo interrupted sharply.
“Stop.”
Helena turned on him.
“No. You’ve lost the right to decide when people stop talking.”
Then she faced Camille again.
“What did Mara discover?”
Camille swallowed.
“That Theo had been transferring money.”
Helena frowned.
“Money?”
“Large amounts.”
“How large?”
“Almost ninety thousand dollars.”
Helena looked at Theo in disbelief.
They were married.
They had shared their lives, their plans, and everything Helena believed mattered.
At least, that was what she had always thought.
“Where did it go?”
Theo said nothing.
Simon suddenly stepped forward.
“Answer her.”
Theo finally looked at Helena.
“To someone named Rebecca Vale.”
Helena searched her memory for the name.
She couldn’t place it.
“Who is Rebecca?”
“My mother.”
Helena went still.
Theo’s mother was Diane.
Helena had met Diane dozens of times over the years.
“No, she isn’t.”
“My biological mother.”
That admission felt different from everything else Helena had heard so far.
Theo leaned back against the car.
“I was adopted. Diane and my father never wanted people to know.”
Helena couldn’t decide whether she felt angrier or more confused.
“You never told your wife you were adopted?”
“I promised my parents.”
“For twelve years?”
“I was afraid of what else the truth would expose.”
As the explanation continued, Helena learned what had happened at Mara’s engagement party.
Mara had been helping Theo arrange financial paperwork for a mortgage refinance when she discovered the transfers.
She confronted Theo during her engagement celebration.
That was when he finally admitted the truth.
Rebecca Vale, the woman Theo believed was his biological mother, had contacted him two years earlier.
She said she needed money.
Theo began sending her payments without telling Helena.
When Mara found out, she insisted that he tell his wife.
Theo refused.
They argued.
That confrontation was why Mara had walked out of her own engagement party.
Helena’s eyes began burning.
“So Mara stopped speaking to me because she was protecting you?”
“No,” Theo answered. “There’s more.”
Of course there was.
It seemed that every explanation only uncovered another secret.
Theo drew a breath.
“Rebecca didn’t contact me because she needed money.”
Camille suddenly whispered his name.
“Theo.”
“She was being paid.”
Helena stared at him.
“By whom?”
Theo looked directly at Camille.
“Her.”
Simon immediately turned toward his wife.
Camille took a step backward.
“That isn’t fair.”
Helena could barely believe the words coming out of Theo’s mouth.
“You paid his biological mother?”
“No.”
Theo pulled out his phone.
“I found the transfers three days ago.”
He brought up a screenshot of banking transactions.
Helena recognized Camille’s name among the details.
Simon took the phone and examined the screen.
His expression shifted.
“Camille, what is this?”
Camille remained silent.
Simon scrolled through the transactions.
Then he stopped.
“These payments started eight months ago.”
That was seven months before Camille claimed she had become pregnant.
Before the affair with Theo.
Even before Mara’s engagement party.
Helena could feel her heartbeat growing faster.
“So this didn’t start with the affair.”
“No,” Simon replied.
Camille lowered herself onto a chair beside the garage wall.
“I can explain.”
Helena let out a short, disbelieving laugh.
“That sentence should be printed on all of your clothes.”
Simon crouched in front of Camille.
“Explain.”
Camille looked past him toward Helena.
“I needed Rebecca to confirm something.”
“What?”
“Whether Theo had a hereditary condition.”
Theo frowned.
“What condition?”
Camille’s hands were trembling.
“Infertility.”
Helena stared at her for a moment.
Then a sharp laugh escaped her.
“I’m pregnant.”
“I know.”
Camille answered so quickly that Helena immediately stopped laughing.
“What do you mean, you know?”
Camille glanced at the pregnancy test.
“I saw you buy it yesterday.”
Helena remembered running into Camille near the pharmacy the previous day.
Camille had told her she was there to pick up allergy medicine.
Simon rose slowly to his feet.
“Why were you investigating Theo’s fertility?”
Camille closed her eyes.
“Because of Helena.”
Helena felt as though the room had shifted beneath her.
“What about me?”
Camille’s answer came in a whisper.
“You weren’t supposed to get pregnant naturally.”
The story isn’t over yet. Select “Next Part” below to see what happens next.
